Mendham Boro Commits $10K To Study Regional School Dissolution

Mendham Boro Council agrees to fund the first step towards breaking up the West Morris Regional School District.

Armed with a 16-page presentation, Mendham Borough resident Brian Cavanaugh came to Tuesday's meeting of the mayor and council and asked that they spend $10,000 to fund a study as the first step in a process to break up the school district.

And before he even opened his mouth to speak, Mendham Borough Mayor Neil Henry agreed to commit the money.

"I've read your presentation and while we disagree on some of the points we agree that the funding formula is inequitable and needs to be fixed," Henry said. "I think its fair to say we can authorize to spend the $10,000."

Cavanaugh is one of several emmissaries speaking out to governing bodies and boards of education in hopes of drumming up support for the study. Cavanaugh's presentation stated there is a $6.6 million dollar imbalance in the funding of the current regional district and suggested dissolving the current school district and creating a new school district that would serve the Mendhams and the Chesters. 

"The first step is to fund a feasibility study to assist in the evaluation of alternatives before submitting a single alternative to the voting public within the sending municipalities," Cavanaugh said in his report (which is attached as a PDF to this post).

According to figures provided by Cavanaugh, an investment of $10,000 for the feasibility study would generate $1.6 million dollars a year for Mendham Borough residents.

Cavanaugh said in his report the timing was right to pursue this agenda because the census numbers showed the population of Mendham and Chester eclipsed that of Washington Township.

Washington Township "can no longer keep us from passing the referendum," Cavanaugh's report said.

Cavanaugh said that concerned citizens have been working for years to help elected officials understand the "subsidy is unfair and is hurting our schools." Cavanaugh said the regional board of education tabled the issue and the mayors meetings with all the municipalities did not work.

"We know you guys worked hard at other avenues," Cavanaugh said. "But unfortunately it didn't work."

Cavanaugh said in his report that Washington Township was not an economically disadvantaged community.

"I'm sure they like taking out money, but they don't need our subsidy," Cavanaugh's presentation said.

Cavanaugh said that the Mendham Borough Council already appropriated the money for the purpose of a feasibility study and did not spend it or return it to the taxpayers.

"I know I didn't get a check for my portion of it," Cavanaugh said.

Councilman John Andrus said that characterization was too simplistic.

"The point is we can find the money for the study if it is a valid study," Andrus said. "We all think what was going on is unfair. It’s a matter of how to get there."

Mendham Borough resident and substitute teacher Alise Ford had an issue with the price tag being too high for one community and expressed those thoughts to Cavanaugh.

"You've asked the council for $10,000 and now you are going to ask the K-8 board for $10,000 so as a Mendham Borough taxpayer I am going to shell out $20,000 out of $50,000?" Ford asked.

Cavanaugh said that they weren't sure how much money would be needed, depending on how many boards of education and governing bodies participated. 

"We may ask Chester for $20,000. We don't know yet," Cavanaugh said.

Henry said the council would have the money for the study, but would discuss it further at the next meeting.

"This was a quick turnaround," Henry said. "We need a little time to digest."

Noreen Staples February 20, 2013 at 11:43 AM
This is long overdue! Kudos to Mendham Borough for stepping up!
Beach Mover February 20, 2013 at 01:48 PM
I will do the study for $100. You will save money in the short term for local taxpayers.The other districts will have to pay more in taxes. They will not vote to break up district. In the not too distant future there will be a state or county BOE and save everybody money. Please forward $100 to my pay pal account number xxxxxxx.
Jerry Gordon February 20, 2013 at 02:51 PM
This is a waste of money.
Domino February 20, 2013 at 03:01 PM
It sounds like the outcome of the study has been determined before it has even started. The validity of that power point presentation wouldn't pass muster in a tiddly-winks factory. Who is the 10K being provided to? Who is managing the funds and who decides how and what it is being spent on? Certainly the money cannot be given to CBS or any of these fly-by-night alphabet soup organizations that have appeared on the scene. It certainly cannot be managed by Mr. Schrier's pal, Jamie Button; that is a clear conflict of interest. This Mendham Borough Council failed to ask enough questions and folded like a cheap suit. Shame on all of you.
jj schrier February 20, 2013 at 04:41 PM
Another stupid post by "Domina". What a waste of hot air by an ignoramus coward. Feh! Ptooey. Maybe "it" could star in Dinner for Schmucks II.
Beach Mover February 20, 2013 at 05:01 PM
JJ Schrier why are you so nasty to anybody that disagrees with you? Just state your case and go on.
Henry Krinkle February 20, 2013 at 05:03 PM
It has all become such a tired old joke and such a waste of time, money, and worst of all, taxpayers' patience. Who do they think they are kidding with another lame dead-end study?! It's just another diversionary stall tactic of smoke and mirrors which could justifiably result in the current elected officials becoming ejected officials by a disgusted and neglected populace. No joke, folks.
Henry Krinkle February 20, 2013 at 05:10 PM
Some folks are blessed and mellow with age...crusty old politicians seem to just get crankier.
LV Common Sense February 20, 2013 at 05:22 PM
I thought it needed to be unanimous to get changed, not just a majority. Is this not the case?
Domino February 20, 2013 at 05:23 PM
I guess this is what a class act looks like: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YB7xEKBTcVs
12345678 February 20, 2013 at 06:05 PM
Well ain't that embarrassing.. I wonder if he remembers it now?? haha
Cristen February 20, 2013 at 06:17 PM
The CBS crowd can keep telling everyone that they can break apart the WMRHSD but that doesn't make it so. A study is just a first step, but in the end voter approval by all communities is required, then the state gets a say. No other district has been successful in kicking out one of their towns for a perceived iniquity because state law created the problem. The NJ DOE gave a presentation at Mendham HS on this exact topic with accurate information (as opposed to what's in the CBS spreadsheet). If CBS wanted a solution, they would support the Mayor's efforts to get Trenton to solve the problem, but I think the real goal is to drive away the current hardworking elected officials for their own personal power grab.
McDuff February 20, 2013 at 09:04 PM
Cristen, you no longer live in Long Valley and what you think of the WMRHSD's circumstances is now irrelevant. That being said, maybe you can help the Mendham and Chester readers understand why it is so wrong for their taxpayers to work so hard to bring back the $6.6 million that is delivered annually into the outstretched hands of Long Valley citizens. I guess it's okay for Long Valley to take this money, but according to Mayor Short, Long Valley certainly does not want to find itself in any shared service situations with our towns where Long Valley finds itself footing more than its share of the bill (see http://mendham-chester.patch.com/articles/shared-services-a-focus-of-mayors-meeting). After all, Mayor Short is quoted saying the following: “I’d really like to explore shared services with the other mayors,” Short said. “What are the cost savings in certain areas? Let’s explore those. But we have to remember one town can’t benefit on behalf of another–there has to be sacrifice on both ends.” With regard to the WMRHSD funding, where is Long Valley's sacrifice? Mayor Short shut down the process by insisting on a mega K-12 study, knowing full well that two of the sending towns were not going to agree to that. Big sacrifice, Mayor Short. Keep drinking the kool-aid Cristen.
ReasonRules February 20, 2013 at 11:20 PM
Oh my goodness - enough already with this! Waste of time & money...
Noreen Staples February 21, 2013 at 01:43 AM
So I guess we should just keep the status quo?
Claire February 25, 2013 at 02:03 PM
Interesting article in the Obs Trib. http://newjerseyhills.com/observer-tribune/news/surrender-out-of-the-question-in-chester-township/article_b45b44dc-7c19-11e2-8afe-0019bb2963f4.html The superintendent explains that most of the cost difference is due to teachers salaries between the 2 schools. I guess some equate a better teacher is a higher paid one. Maybe they need some shuffling of teachers between the schools. The other portion was mostly due to special ed cost. try fighting that issue ...
Noreen Staples February 25, 2013 at 02:22 PM
Thank you mr Gordon and mr Schrier for posting under your given names! ( i think)
Claire February 25, 2013 at 07:35 PM
Noreen, I am not sure if your comment was directed at me, but I would never post under my name, not with all the crazy people in town. I have lived here too long and know too many people. I would never put myself or my kids in that position. I would not want to defend myself in the shoprite parking lot. I try to bring up reasonable points and educate. BTW, I think its great you are collecting Prom Gowns for a good cause. You seem to be a good person that I would be friends with.
Noreen Staples February 25, 2013 at 07:48 PM
Obviously this just my opinion, and yesI have been berated on these pages and it hurts a lot! But.....I feel it is too easy to attack and throw barbs at people when you are hiding! I believe in transparency and accountability. I do try and refrain from responding to things which will have repercussions to my family. Because sadly, some people are mean. I think it is important to hear both sides. I may hear something I didn't think of and or know, which might leag to growth or learning. The attacking is wrong. And Again hiding behind a fake name makes it easy. If we all believed in the same thing....this world would be boring. @claire my point was not directed at you in particular, you just stated your case which helps open minded people see a different side or lastly more information. Thank you for your kind words.
LVMom February 28, 2013 at 02:32 PM
I live in long valley and honestly i don't think we are helping ourselves with the 'joint' school thing. in many other towns joint schools mean school choice, it means each school offers something different and the families have a choice as to where to go. here we just have 2 schools that spend all there time doing their own thing. fighting with each other and making the kids in each town feel as if they are adversaries. as the town with WAY less income, and home values any 'state and federal' aid would come with us. so i say do it. it would also mean we could drop the BS of IB go all AP and put an amazing program in place. for those who want to study abroad then go for the AP international degree. we can teach 'world view' without the IB name. colleges actually get a copy of the class description and know what is being studied.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something